On a social media platform this week a university lecturer posed this important question. She is involved with a course for trainee teachers. I really took this question to heart, BUT I have to say SO many of the 'answers' left me in despair.
Here is the question:
If you were choosing one Australian middle-grade novel (around Grades 3–4 level) to share with a group of young adults who are preparing to be primary teachers—many of whom haven’t read children’s novels for a while—what book would you pick that they simply won’t be able to put down? We’ll be reading part of the book aloud together each week, and they’ll read the rest between classes. I’d love a story that reminds them of the joy and magic of reading and shows the power of a great book in the classroom. What Australian page-turner would you choose?
Before I share my 'long' reply let's just look at some key aspects of this question - things we know and things that lead to more questions:
- The question comes from someone involved in tertiary education here in Australia so that explains the emphasis on 'Australian' - this is okay but I hope the lecturer will also expose these adult students to other books. We speak English here in Australia and so have access to some of the best books from UK, Canada, USA, New Zealand and South Africa.
- Grade 3 and 4 - Is this for a book to read at the beginning of the year when the Grade 3 kids have just moved out of an infants grade. These readers could be aged between 7 and 10 depending on when this project happens. I would argue there is a huge difference between books I would share with a Grade 3 reader aged 7 turning 8 and a Grade 4 reader aged 9 turning 10.
- "Won't be able to put down" - that is actually impossible to predict but it is a worthy goal. These University students may not be 'readers' or they may be avid adult readers, they may have preferred genres, and I have to say finding ONE book feels like a huge responsibility. Perhaps it might be better to use one text for this 'book club' model but also give the students a wide reading list and set a requirement to read a set number of these too.
- "I’d love a story that reminds them of the joy and magic of reading and shows the power of a great book in the classroom" - this is a lofty goal - I do hope a book that fulfils this can be found. If we weren't limited to Australian I would have suggested Wishtree by Katherine Applegate or One Dog and his Boy by Eva Ibbotson.
POST UPDATE - here is a reply from the author of this question. (I would prefer not to name the Facebook group):
- Thank you for your thoughtful post and for sharing it with me. Since I’m the lecturer who posed the original question, I thought it might be helpful to offer a little context.
- Teaching future primary teachers about thoughtful, intentional book selection is just one small part of what they explore in this subject with the teaching team. Over the semester, students look closely at a range of considerations—developmental suitability, reader experience, literary quality, diversity of texts, and how we support children to engage with longer works of fiction in purposeful ways.
- For many pre-service teachers, it has been quite a long time since they’ve read junior–middle fiction, and for some, a long time since they’ve read any long-form fiction at all. Before they can meaningfully evaluate and select texts for children, they need structured opportunities to re-engage with children’s literature as readers.
- As experienced teachers, we know that you cannot “teach” a book unless you have lived with it—read it multiple times, considered it from different angles, and explored its possibilities. Asking the cohort to read one shared text over time allows us to model this process deliberately and to help rebuild reading stamina in a manageable, supportive way.
- I also asked specifically for Australian titles—not because I’m opposed to international literature (far from it), but because we have such exceptional Australian authors and I enjoy highlighting their work. It’s important for future teachers to be familiar with a strong range of local stories as part of their wider reading diet.
- And as for choosing the Year 3–4 range—there was no special reason beyond instinct. I imagined the books might be shorter, and my experience is that while they may be shorter, they are certainly not less mighty or less worth reading. It also meant there was a good chance we would get through the book in the time we have scheduled.
Now back to my response to the original question. This particular forum/Facebook Group does not allow contributors to link to personal blog posts but all of the books I offered as choices (see image below) are discussed here on my blog of course. Here is my reply:
I think it would be good to have a book (if you’re in NSW) that’s not one of the “set” English texts. It would be good to “expand their knowledge. Also grade 3 and 4 kids are very different. If this is now, late in the year, then the grade 3 kids are aged 9 and grade 4 kids are ten but if it’s for term one next year the grade 3 kids are still quite young.
Also, if I was doing this, I’d seek out a book that doesn’t have existing teachers notes or discussion questions, so these trainee teachers have to think deeply about the text. I also think a shorter book would be good, so the task is not too daunting. And perhaps you could use a verse novel because some of these students may not have encountered that form and they often have very powerful stories. Someone already suggested The Little wave for example.
Here’s some novels to investigate.
Pop each title into my search bar for me details
Hopefully you’re able to read a few for yourself so you can give these lucky students a fabulous reading experience. I’ll post a few verse novels too.
Verse Novels - Pop each title into my search bar for more details
I’m also guessing as well as Australian it needs to be in print. My most favourite book for a project like this would be The Big Bazoohley by Peter Carey but it’s long out of print. I also love another very old book Angie’s ankles by Gary Hurle but that disappeared a long time ago. Can you let the group know which book you do use? Thanks. (Sorry for this long answer but I think this is a very very important topic). AND I would add that the best books we share with students are books we have loved reading ourselves - not texts imposed by curriculum experts or even grade requirements etc.
Of course, I have no way of knowing about the expertise of the people who shared their own answers to the question I quoted.
I have organised the books that were listed under my own headings -
The Good
Leo and Ralph by Peter Carnavas
The Little Wave by Pip Harry
The Kindness Project by Deb Abela
Katrina Nannestad - I would say yes to some of her books but not the World War II titles. The Travelling Bookshop
Polly and Buster by Sally Rippin
The Book of Wondrous possibilities by Deb Abela
The Midwatch by Judith Rossell (but this one is very long)
Wandi by Favel Parrett
Mina and the whole wide world by Sherryl Clark (might be out of print)
Song of a Thousand Seas by Zana Fraillon
Brindabella by Ursula Dubosarsky
Too mainstream - I would love these students to be exposed to 'other books' not the latest 'top of the pops books' even though I did enjoy some of these:
Runt by Craig Silvey (I have four other posts about this book and the sequel)
Blueback by Tim Winton - here in NSW this is a prescribed text
How to be Prime Minister and Survive Grade Five by Carla Fitzgerald
Rowan of Rin by Emily Rodda (1993)
The Naming of Tishkin silk by Glenda Millard (I am a huge fan of this series of seven titles, and I own the whole set but in the first one the baby has died - younger readers might find this distressing).
Childish by Morris Gleitzman (Take a look at one his less well known titles that I loved)
The Strange choices (in my view)
YES, these are great books, but I wouldn't suggest them for this project
Nevermoor by Jessica Townsend (this has 450 pages)
The extremely inconvenient adventures of Bronte Mettlestone by Jaclyn Moriarty (494 pages)
Bob by Wendy Mass and Rebecca Stead illustrated by Nicholas Gannon - this is a fantastic book with an Australian setting BUT the authors are from the US.
Books I would not read with or to children aged 7-10
Playing Beatie Bow by Ruth Park (distressing scenes and the main character is a teenager)
Once by Morris Gleitzman (Holocaust setting)
August and Jones by Pip Harry
Books by Tristan Bancks - I love his work - Scar Town; Two Wolves; Detention; and Cop and Robber
The Shop at Hoopers Bend by Emily Rodda
Sick Bay by Nova Weetman
Laugher is the best ending by Mariam Master
A Glasshouse of Stars by Shirley Marr
Harp in the South by Ruth Park (adult title)
His name was Walter Emily Rodda (the characters in this book are teenagers)
Dragon Skin Karen Foxlee (contains domestic violence)
Lenny's book of Everything by Karen Foxlee
Any of the James Aldridge (he died in 2015 and his books are Young Adult titles) I loved The Story of Lilli Stubeck from 1984.
Childstone Cycle by Kerry Greenwood (adult title)
Jackie French Matilda series (Young Adult/Adult series)
Queenie in Seven Moves by Zanni Louise
Does my head look big in this by Randa Abdel Fattah
Out of Print
45 and 47 Stella Street by Elizabeth Honey
The Cabbage Patch Fib by Paul Jennings
The Stupendously Spectacular Spelling bee by Deborah Abela
Benjamin in Blink Beyond by Oona Roach (1983)
Not Australian
The Hobbit by JRR Tolkein
The Miraculous journey of Edward Tulane by Kate DiCamillo
The Phantom Tollbooth by Norman Juster
Books I need to find and read:
Big Magic by Sarah Armstrong
This Camp is Doomed by Anna Zobel
Losing the Plot and Down the Plot Hole by Annaleise Byrd
A Clue for Clara by Lian Tanner
The sugarcane kids and the red-bottom boat by Charlie Archbold
The last Ember by Lily Berlin Dodd (not Australian)
Kip of the Karoo and Kip of the Mountain by Emma Gourlay
SOS: Big Splash: School of Scallywags (SOS) by Cameron Stelzer (there are ten titles in this series)
Samantha Wheeler titles - Turtle Trackers; Wombat Warriors; Devils in Danger
This would be SO perfect - I wish it was still in print.